Reading With Fakename: Cleaving

Subtitled “A Story of Marriage, Meat, and Obsession”.  It’s the second book by Julie Powell, author of Julie and Julia.    I guess it was fairly clear in that first book that Julie was a bit…quirky.  If only that she set a goal for herself of cooking all 524 recipes in Julia Child’s Mastering the Art of French Cooking in one year.  For no particular reason, other than that she was restless.  And felt unaccomplished.  (My take on it.)  So it should come as no surprise to anyone that in her second book, Julie has gone way beyond quirky. 

She’s had some fame and success now, and money, and it has given her the freedom to move all the way from quirky into crazy. 

This book is uncomfortable to read.  Quoting from her acknowledgements, she says, “Thanks to my editor, Judy Clain, and her assistant, Nathan Rostron, who edit adroitly and remind me from time to time that there is such a thing as too much information.”  Well Julie, maybe they didn’t remind you often enough. 

When we meet up again with Julie in the beginning of this book, she is engaged in two more projects.  Project 1 is carrying on an affair with a man we know only as D.  We get to hear more than we would like about some specifics of their encounters, which become increasingly masochistic on her part without her seeming to realize it.  The problem is that while these encounters are described somewhat explicitly, there is no eroticism in them.  They are sad. 

Project 2 is that she has become an apprentice butcher.  Why she would want to do that is inexplicable.  But I would say, Julie has power issues.  In a perverse sort of way, the more she surrendered to D, the freer she felt, and that feeling of freedom gave her the illusion of power.  The butchery was more complicated.  You got a window into why Julie might choose this in the first book, when she seemed far too proud of herself, in my opinion, when she was able to stab a lobster to death on her kitchen table.  Of course, she was only following orders.  That’s how Julia said to do it. 

The butchery is described in even more explicit detail, and there is just about as much discomfort engendered there.  But it’s a bit hypocritical to be a meat-eater and yet be too squeamish to learn how it gets into those nice wrapped packages in the grocery store.  Butchery turns out to be quite an art; yes, it requires some brute force but it also requires skill and endurance.  Julie becomes very good at it, and that feeling of accomplishment is all that keeps her sane as her affair and her marriage (yes, she’s still married to Mr. Alleged Soulmate whom we met in the first book) are falling apart. 

Then, she developed carpal tunnel in the wrist of her cutting hand, which is excruciatingly painful.  And still she won’t quit.  That’s when you grasp that what we have here is the same old Julie.  It’s just a different form of masochism. 

At last the 6-month apprenticeship is over, the affair is over–at least from D’s perspective–and her husband is now having his own affair. 

So she takes a trip by herself…a “meat tour”, which begins in Argentina.  It’s in Tanzania that the event happens that seems to change Julie (finally!)  She’s the victim of an attempted rape in her tent.  Her response is to push the man away and tell him she isn’t interested, and shine the light from her cell phone on his face.  She could have cried out for help–there are people in other tents within easy reach, but she does not.  He leaves, but some hours later, she wakes up to find him on top of her.  What is her response?  She feels around for her cellphone–that most powerful of weapons.  Again she manages to talk him into leaving, but if you’re me, you’re like…

Goddamn it, Julie!  If there was ever a time to give up your stupid control issues and your masochism and your self-loathing, this is it!  Scream, you idiot!  She does not, but he does leave again.  In the morning, she at least tells her traveling companions…and justice is done.  I’m not sure why this changed her, but it did. 

Cooking still plays a role in this book, and there are 15 recipes that tell the tale of her journey through the mysteries of, as she announces in the subtitle, marriage, meat, and obsession.  I wouldn’t say it has a happy ending, but it has a satisfying ending.  At least, one less awful than I feared.


4 responses to “Reading With Fakename: Cleaving

  1. mmmmmmmmmm pass…………but thanks for sharing…….i read the new “Reacher” novel 61 Hours in 38 hours………….don’t know what that means except that Child has my number.

    Happy Deb:) you will have a hoot with her.

  2. Yes, pt 🙂 This was not a book I could wholeheartedly recommend, but it has a certain logic to it that you recognize flows completely from the first one. Much darker. And believe it or not, the butchery descriptions were quite educational.
    Thanks for the alert to the new “Reacher”.

  3. With Fakesister’s permission, a copy of her email to me referring to carpal tunnel syndrome.
    I read your book review where the author gets carpal tunnel syndrome while
    training to be a butcher …

    I happen to be reading “Always Follow the Elephants” which is about medical
    myths and facts. One of the vignettes is about carpal tunnel: Do computer
    keyboards cause carpal tunnel syndrome?

    The gist is that keyboard workers suffer from carpal tunnel syndrome at the
    same rate as the general population. Ergo, keyboarding is no worse for you
    than being alive.

    However, folks who do assembly-line work in manufacturing and in
    meat-packing be it meat, poultry, or fish have three times the rate of
    carpal tunnel as the general population. Women are three times as likely to
    have it as men, most likely because the carpal tunnel is physically smaller
    in women and therefore more easily impinges on the median nerve.

    Any job that requires heavy lifting or high stress to the wrist area, like
    butchering meat, carries a high risk of carpal tunnel syndrome.

    Desk jobs do have their pitfalls but this is apparently not one of them.

  4. And as I replied to Fakesister, I always thought that keyboard/carpal tunnel syndrome thing was bullshit. More like the two people who are suing us…good way to get money from the company without actually having to work for it. This is the world we live in.
    But back to science 🙂 As Julie gets better and stronger at the job, her wrist muscles grow, and it made me wonder if that in and of itself put pressure on the nerve.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s